# Flour vs Cornstarch for Thickening Gravy

Learn how flour and cornstarch thicken gravy differently, how to mix each one without lumps, and how to pick the right thickener for the texture you want.

Flour and cornstarch both thicken gravy, but they behave differently in the pan. Flour needs fat and a few minutes of cooking to lose its raw taste, while cornstarch thickens fast and gives a glossy, clear sauce. The choice comes down to the texture and color you want and what you already have in the pantry. 

- Flour thickens through a roux of fat and starch, so it suits gravy built on pan drippings.
- Cornstarch works as a cold slurry and gives a clear, glossy gravy with a lighter body.
- Cornstarch breaks down under long boiling, so add it near the end of cooking.
- Mix either thickener with a cool liquid before it meets the hot gravy to avoid lumps.
- A gravy that thins after standing can be brought back with a little more slurry.
 

## How flour and cornstarch thicken differently 

Flour thickens gravy when its starch granules absorb liquid and swell during heating. Fat coats the flour particles in a roux, which keeps them separate so the gravy stays smooth. The flour also needs enough heat to cook through and shed its raw cereal taste. 

Cornstarch thickens gravy in much the same swelling way, but the granules burst sooner and release a clear gel. A cornstarch gravy looks glossy and translucent rather than opaque. It also sets more firmly as it cools, which can make leftovers look jelled. 

The two thickeners therefore give different results from the same pan of drippings. Flour builds body and a savory, toasted flavor when it is browned. Cornstarch adds thickness with little color and a lighter mouthfeel, which suits pan drippings you want to keep bright. 

## Building a roux with flour and fat 

A roux is equal parts flour and fat cooked together before liquid goes in. The fat can be butter, oil, or the drippings left in the roasting pan. Cook the paste for a minute or two to remove the raw flour taste, and stir it constantly so it does not scorch. 

Pour the stock or milk in gradually while whisking, and the roux will dissolve into the liquid. A darker roux thickens less than a pale one because heat weakens the starch. If the gravy looks thin after the liquid is in, simmer it uncovered and stir now and then until it tightens. 

Roux-based gravy suits pan drippings from roasted meat because the fat is already there. Skim off excess fat first and keep a few spoonfuls for the roux. A roux also freezes well, so a batch made ahead shortens the work on a busy day. 

## Making a cornstarch slurry 

A slurry is cornstarch stirred into a cold liquid such as water, stock, or milk. The cold liquid separates the starch grains so they disperse evenly when they hit the hot gravy. Add the slurry in a thin stream while whisking, then simmer briefly until the gravy thickens. 

Cornstarch needs only a short simmer to activate, and long boiling breaks the gel down. Add a cornstarch slurry near the end of cooking, once the gravy tastes right. If the gravy must simmer longer, hold the slurry back until the final minutes. 

Cornstarch gravy turns cloudy if it is stirred with a whisk that scrapes up browned bits from the pan. Strain the drippings first if you want a clear, glossy result. The slurry also thickens sauces for stir-fries and fruit desserts where a transparent shine is welcome. 

## Choosing between flour and cornstarch 

Flour suits a gravy that will cook for a while, such as one simmered with onions or herbs. It holds up to longer heat and gives a rounded, opaque body. Cornstarch suits a quick pan gravy finished at the last minute, especially when the drippings are light in color. 

Consider what the gravy is for. A flour gravy coats mashed potatoes and roast meat with a sturdy texture. A cornstarch gravy glazes sliced meat or vegetables with a shiny, lighter coating. Neither is a substitute for the other at the same quantity. 

Cornstarch is the stronger thickener spoon for spoon, so a slurry uses less of it than a roux uses flour. Follow a tested ratio when swapping, and add thickener in stages until the gravy reaches the body you want. The table below compares the two on the points that matter in the pan. 
| Point | Flour | Cornstarch | 
| How it is mixed | Roux with fat | Cold slurry | 
| Look of the gravy | Opaque | Clear and glossy | 
| Heat tolerance | Holds up to long simmering | Breaks down with long boiling | 
| Flavor | Toasted when browned | Neutral | 
| Use in pan drippings | Fat for the roux is already there | Skim fat, then add slurry |  

## Preventing lumps in either gravy 

Gravy lumps come from starch that clumps before it can disperse. Flour clumps when it meets hot liquid without fat to coat it. Cornstarch clumps when it is stirred into a warm base instead of a cold one. The fix for both is the same: separate the starch in a cool medium first. 

Whisk the roux or slurry into the liquid rather than dumping it in one lump. Add liquid to roux in small pours at the start, and whisk the pan constantly. A flat whisk reaches the corners of the pan where starch settles and sticks. 

If lumps still form, pour the gravy through a fine sieve into a clean pot. Press the lumps against the mesh with a spoon and discard what stays behind. Return the smooth gravy to low heat and taste it before serving. 

## Fixing gravy that is too thin or too thick 

Thin gravy usually needs more thickener or more simmering time. For flour gravy, simmer uncovered and stir so moisture evaporates. For cornstarch gravy, whisk a fresh slurry of cornstarch and cold water and add it in small amounts. 

Thick gravy can be loosened with a splash of stock, milk, or water. Add the liquid a spoonful at a time and whisk well before judging. Cornstarch gravy thickens further as it cools, so loosen it slightly more than looks right in the hot pan. 

Gravy that thinned after standing may have been boiled too long or lacked enough starch. Reheat it gently and stir in a little slurry if the body is gone. A gravy that has separated can often be brought back with steady whisking over low heat. 

## Matching the thickener to texture preferences 

Texture is the main reason to pick one thickener over the other. Flour gives a full, velvety body that sits on the tongue. Cornstarch gives a slick, light body with a shine that reflects light on the plate. 

Some eaters prefer a gravy with no flour taste and a clean finish, which points to cornstarch. Others want the hearty, roasted depth that a browned roux brings. Serving both styles at one meal is easy when you thicken portions separately. 

For a gluten-free gravy, cornstarch works without wheat flour at all. A cornstarch gravy also suits a dairy-free pan sauce when the slurry is made with water or stock. Check labels on any packaged stock if gluten matters to your household. 

## Storing and reheating thickened gravy 

Flour gravy keeps its body well when chilled and reheated, though it may need a stir and a splash of liquid. Cornstarch gravy can turn grainy or weep after freezing because the gel structure breaks. Reheat either gravy gently and whisk as it warms. 

Cool leftover gravy quickly and store it in a shallow container in the refrigerator. Bring it to a simmer before serving and stir the bottom of the pot. Gravy that has been left out at room temperature should be discarded rather than reheated. 

Reheated cornstarch gravy sometimes looks jelled when cold and loosens as it warms. Stir it over low heat and add liquid only if it stays thick. A fresh slurry stirred into the reheated gravy restores body without changing the flavor much. 

## Questions about flour and cornstarch gravy 

### Can I use cornstarch instead of flour to thicken gravy? 

Yes, cornstarch can replace flour in gravy, but it is mixed as a cold slurry rather than a roux. Cornstarch thickens more strongly spoon for spoon, so start with less and add more if needed. The finished gravy will look clear and glossy instead of opaque. 

### Why did my cornstarch gravy turn thin? 

Cornstarch gravy turns thin when it is boiled for a long time, because heat breaks the starch gel apart. It can also thin if too little cornstarch was used for the amount of liquid. Add a fresh slurry near the end of cooking and simmer only until the gravy thickens. 

### How do I keep flour gravy from tasting raw? 

Flour gravy tastes raw when the roux is not cooked long enough before the liquid goes in. Cook the flour and fat together for a minute or two, stirring, until the paste smells toasted. Then add the liquid gradually and simmer the gravy to finish cooking the starch. 

### Does cornstarch gravy freeze well? 

Cornstarch gravy does not freeze well, because the gel can break and turn grainy or watery when thawed. Flour gravy holds its texture better in the freezer. If you freeze cornstarch gravy anyway, whisk it gently during reheating and expect a softer body. 

### Which thickener works better with pan drippings? 

Flour works naturally with pan drippings because the fat in the pan can become the roux. Skim the drippings, keep a little fat, and stir in an equal amount of flour. Cornstarch also works with drippings, but the fat should be skimmed off first and the slurry made with a cold liquid. 

### Can I combine flour and cornstarch in one gravy? 

Yes, flour and cornstarch can be used together in the same gravy. A roux made with flour can be finished with a small cornstarch slurry for extra shine and body. Add the slurry late in cooking and simmer briefly so the cornstarch does not break down.
